Alternatives to Amylase/Papain if You Can't Fill Your Prescription

Updated:

March 26, 2026

Author:

Peter Daggett

Summarize this blog with AI:

Can't find Amylase/Papain? Explore proven digestive enzyme alternatives including bromelain, pancrelipase, lactase, and more to support your digestion.

Alternatives to Amylase/Papain if You Can't Fill Your Prescription

If you rely on Amylase/Papain digestive enzyme supplements and can't find them in stock, you're probably feeling stuck. Digestive discomfort doesn't wait for supply chains to sort themselves out. The good news? There are several effective alternatives that can help you manage bloating, gas, and poor digestion while your preferred product is unavailable.

In this guide, we'll explain what Amylase/Papain does, how it works, and walk you through the best alternatives — so you can make an informed choice with your healthcare provider.

What Is Amylase/Papain?

Amylase/Papain is a combination of two naturally occurring digestive enzymes found in many over-the-counter supplements:

  • Amylase breaks down starches and complex carbohydrates into simpler sugars that your body can absorb.
  • Papain is a proteolytic (protein-digesting) enzyme derived from papaya fruit. It breaks down proteins into smaller peptides and amino acids.

This combination is popular because it addresses two of the most common digestive bottlenecks — carbohydrate and protein digestion — in a single supplement. Products like NaturesPlus Papaya Enzyme chewable tablets and multi-enzyme capsule blends from brands like Double Wood and Dr. Tobias contain this combination.

For a complete overview, see our article on what Amylase/Papain is and how to use it.

How Does Amylase/Papain Work?

When you eat a meal, your body naturally produces digestive enzymes to break down food. Amylase is produced by your salivary glands and pancreas, while your stomach and small intestine produce various proteases.

Supplemental Amylase/Papain works alongside your body's natural enzymes to enhance digestion. Papain specifically works in a wide pH range, meaning it remains active throughout your digestive tract — from the acidic stomach to the more alkaline small intestine. This makes it particularly effective for people whose natural enzyme production may be low due to aging, stress, or digestive conditions.

For a deeper dive into the science, read our article on how Amylase/Papain works.

Alternative 1: Bromelain

Bromelain is a proteolytic enzyme extracted from pineapple stems and juice. Like papain, it breaks down proteins into smaller, more digestible fragments. It also has well-documented anti-inflammatory properties.

Why it's a good alternative:

  • Provides similar protein-digesting activity to papain
  • Widely available as a standalone supplement or in multi-enzyme blends
  • Typically costs $10 to $25 for a 60-120 capsule supply
  • Also used for reducing inflammation and swelling

Things to know: Like papain, bromelain can interact with blood thinners like warfarin. People with pineapple allergy should avoid it. Always check with your doctor before starting bromelain, especially if you take anticoagulant medications.

Alternative 2: Pancrelipase (Creon, Zenpep, Pancreaze)

Pancrelipase is a prescription pancreatic enzyme replacement therapy (PERT) that contains a combination of three enzymes: lipase (for fats), protease (for proteins), and amylase (for carbohydrates). Brand names include Creon, Zenpep, and Pancreaze.

Why it's a good alternative:

  • Contains amylase plus additional enzymes for comprehensive digestion support
  • FDA-approved for exocrine pancreatic insufficiency (EPI) due to cystic fibrosis, chronic pancreatitis, and pancreatectomy
  • Covered by most insurance plans
  • Available in multiple strengths for dose customization

Things to know: Pancrelipase requires a prescription. It's derived from porcine (pig) pancreas, which may not be suitable for everyone. The cash price for Creon without insurance ranges from approximately $300 to $900 per month depending on dose, but most insurance plans cover it. Creon also offers a copay card and patient assistance program.

Alternative 3: Lactase (Lactaid)

If your digestive issues are primarily related to dairy consumption, lactase may be the right alternative. Lactase is the enzyme that breaks down lactose (milk sugar), and a deficiency in this enzyme causes lactose intolerance.

Why it's a good alternative:

  • Specifically targets lactose digestion
  • Available OTC for about $8 to $15 for a 60-100 count supply
  • Very well-tolerated with minimal side effects
  • Fast-acting when taken immediately before or with dairy foods

Things to know: Lactase only addresses lactose digestion. If you need broader enzyme support for proteins and starches, you'll want to combine it with other enzymes or choose a multi-enzyme blend.

Alternative 4: Alpha-Galactosidase (Beano)

Alpha-galactosidase, sold under the brand name Beano, is a digestive enzyme that breaks down complex carbohydrates found in beans, vegetables, and whole grains — the foods most likely to cause gas and bloating.

Why it's a good alternative:

  • Specifically targets gas-producing carbohydrates
  • Widely available at pharmacies and grocery stores for about $8 to $14
  • Can be taken as a chewable tablet or in liquid drops
  • Very safe with few reported side effects

Things to know: Beano only addresses carbohydrate-related gas. It does not break down proteins like papain does. For a more complete alternative, consider pairing Beano with a proteolytic enzyme like bromelain.

How to Choose the Right Alternative

The best alternative depends on your specific digestive needs:

  • For general protein and carbohydrate digestion: A multi-enzyme blend with bromelain and amylase is the closest OTC substitute for Amylase/Papain.
  • For diagnosed pancreatic insufficiency: Talk to your doctor about prescription pancrelipase (Creon, Zenpep, or Pancreaze).
  • For lactose intolerance: Lactase (Lactaid) is the most targeted solution.
  • For gas from beans and vegetables: Alpha-galactosidase (Beano) is your best bet.

Always talk to your healthcare provider before switching enzymes, especially if you have a diagnosed condition, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or take blood thinners.

Final Thoughts

Not being able to find your usual Amylase/Papain supplement is frustrating, but it doesn't mean you have to suffer through digestive discomfort. Bromelain, pancrelipase, lactase, and alpha-galactosidase are all proven alternatives that can help — depending on your specific needs.

Before switching, check Medfinder to see if Amylase/Papain is available near you. And for more information on side effects and drug interactions with any enzyme supplement, read our guide on Amylase/Papain drug interactions.

What is the closest over-the-counter alternative to Amylase/Papain?

A multi-enzyme blend containing bromelain and amylase is the closest OTC alternative. Bromelain provides similar proteolytic (protein-digesting) activity to papain, and many blends also include amylase for carbohydrate digestion. These are widely available for $10 to $25.

Can my doctor prescribe a digestive enzyme to replace Amylase/Papain?

Yes. If you have a diagnosed condition like exocrine pancreatic insufficiency, your doctor can prescribe pancrelipase (brand names Creon, Zenpep, or Pancreaze), which contains amylase, lipase, and protease. These are covered by most insurance plans.

Is bromelain as effective as papain for digestion?

Bromelain and papain are both proteolytic enzymes with similar protein-digesting activity. Research suggests they are comparably effective for general digestive support. Bromelain also offers anti-inflammatory benefits. However, individual responses may vary.

Are there any risks to switching from Amylase/Papain to an alternative enzyme?

Most digestive enzyme alternatives are well-tolerated. However, if you have allergies (such as pineapple allergy for bromelain or latex allergy for papain), take blood thinners, or have a diagnosed digestive condition, you should consult your doctor before switching. Each enzyme has slightly different interactions and contraindications.

Why waste time calling, coordinating, and hunting?

You focus on staying healthy. We'll handle the rest.

Try Medfinder Concierge Free

Medfinder's mission is to ensure every patient gets access to the medications they need. We believe this begins with trustworthy information. Our core values guide everything we do, including the standards that shape the accuracy, transparency, and quality of our content. We’re committed to delivering information that’s evidence-based, regularly updated, and easy to understand. For more details on our editorial process, see here.

25,000+ have already found their meds with Medfinder.

Start your search today.
      What med are you looking for?
⊙  Find Your Meds
99% success rate
Fast-turnaround time
Never call another pharmacy